Country Strong Critics Reviews

Critics Reviews Average Grade:   C+
Source	Brief Review	Grade*
Chicago Sun-Times Roger Ebert	"...a throwback, a pure, heartfelt exercise in '50s social melodrama..." more...	B-
Chicago Tribune Michael Phillips	"...my God is this script predictable." more...	C
Entertainment Weekly Owen Gleiberman	"It shows that Gwyneth knows the spangly high-powered joys of country music. Too bad that in Country Strong, she's too busy acting out the hysterical and mostly nonsensical sorrows." more...	C+
Hollywood Reporter Kirk Honeycutt	"Country weak." more...	C
Los Angeles Times Betsy Sharkey	"The story is an all-too-familiar one, that deadly cocktail of too much fame and too much drink for someone who's lost touch with who she really is anymore." more...	C+
USA Today Claudia Puig	"...feels powerfully familiar" more...	B-

References: Yahoo Movies

Country Strong - Film Review

‘Country Strong‘ has a killer cast, some great songs, but the film delves into every country music stereotype that will make even the most diehard country music fan cringe.

 Director/writer Shana Feste got an amazing cast to headline her ‘Country Strong‘ movie, but if you’re going to make a behind the scene country music film, just stuffing it with every stereotypical country music storyline isn’t enough. After watching ‘Country Strong’, I was left wondering if Feste was aware that there were some great great films out there already about the country music scene like ‘Nashville‘, ‘Coal Miner’s Daughter‘, ‘Crazy Heart‘, ‘Walk The Line’ just to name a few. While they had pick-up trucks, boozing and broads, these films also had characters you could root for who didn’t seem to go against what they were claiming to stand for. This is the type of film that will make people who hate country music feel even more justified, and that’s sad since this is a top notch cast doing the best they can with the one note roles they’re given.

Gwyneth Paltrow has already proven that she can sing and sing really well, but just when she’s about to let it all out in this film, Feste has made her collapse on stage so we never fully get to see her belt out like she did on ‘Glee‘. I was really excited to see Tim McGraw pair with Garret Hedlund again after ‘Friday Night Lights’, but it wasn’t near the same either. McGraw gets to play the self-pitying guy again, but it’s that one note role we’ve seen a thousand times before, and oddly enough, he doesn’t sing one song in this film. One of the top country stars today in a movie about country music, and he doesn’t sing? That’s pretty much the mentality of this entire film which just makes you shake your head many times.
Here’s just one example of something that seems more like it would’ve been in the bizarre comedy ‘Sordid Lives‘ rather than in a film starring Gwyneth Paltrow. Her character carries around a baby bird that she rescued from an abandoned nest. This is her symbolic substitute for the fetus she lost when a drunken fall onstage caused a miscarriage. All of us watching the film let out such a loud groan it wound up turning into the one funny moment of the film…unintentional that it was.
Garrett Hedlund (Tron: Legacy) and Leighton Meester (Gossip Girl) provide the other surprises musical performances that perk up your interest slightly, but when the music ends, their characters are just as convoluted as the rest. Here’s a synopsis of the relationship that ensues that’s the structure of ‘Country Strong’.

 

Country Strong - Plot Summary

A drama centered on a rising country-music songwriter (Hedlund) who sparks with a fallen star (Paltrow). Together, they mount his ascent and her comeback, which leads to romantic complications involving her husband/manager (McGraw) and a beauty queen-turned-singer (Meester).

Below are some pictures of the upcoming movie, Country Song, directed by Shana Feste.